Log entry Nº 215 · the stack watch

Bearing SE 135° · October 30, 2026 · 4 min read

Advertising TechSE 135°Watch log

Spyware in 120,000 Sites: Why Apple's ID Block Isn't the Villain Story

Apple blocked identity-resolution domains in WebKit after spyware hit ads on 120,000 sites and 70,000 apps. The industry's vendor lists didn't catch it — and that changes the blame math.

By Amara Osei4 min read804 words

Can We Really Blame Apple For Blocking ID Tech?
Fix Nº 215Can We Really Blame Apple For Blocking ID Tech? — JESHOOTS-com / pixabay

Ads carrying mercenary spyware reached more than 120,000 websites and 70,000 apps before anyone in ad tech's compliance machinery noticed. That's the number to hold onto when weighing Apple's latest crackdown on third-party identity tech.

On October 15, ad security firm Confiant and the University of Toronto's Citizen Lab confirmed a zero-click spyware attack delivered through targeted advertising. Technology from two Israeli companies — ad tech vendor Discover-Tech and spyware firm Candiru — was used to spy on staff at Al Jazeera. The attackers' customers could pick a person to profile or infect using three identifiers: a mobile advertising ID, a browser cookie ID, or an IP address.

Citizen Lab senior researcher Wolfie Christl, one of the report's authors, told Forbes: "It's difficult, if not almost impossible, to consistently protect yourself from malicious ads. Ad blocking must now be considered a cybersecurity best practice."

That report landed mid-polemic. Since iOS 27 shipped, Apple's WebKit — the engine behind Safari and every browser on iPhone, including Chrome — has blocked requests to a set of ad tech domains handling cross-site tracking. The macOS 27 Golden Gate update did the same for desktop Safari. On October 19, a WebKit blog post explained the common thread: the blocked domains are all "identity resolution infrastructure."

In plain terms: Apple put third-party ID resolution on notice.

Does ad tech have legitimate complaints here?

Yes, and they're real. The industry has faced a month of silence from Apple — no published blocklist, no appeals channel. In at least one documented case, Google could bid on iOS inventory while The Trade Desk could not. Blunt, silent enforcement is counterproductive and unfair.

But Apple has legitimate concerns too, and the spyware report shows why.

Can Apple treat identity as a security matter?

Mathieu Roche, CEO of ID5 — one of the vendors blocked — called the move "an attack against the business model of the web." That framing has circulated since at least 2021, when the programmatic open marketplace rebranded itself as the open web.

Here's the rub: ad tech's role doesn't require finding one person across 120,000 sites and 70,000 apps. Yet that's exactly what the open marketplace is built on — and what attackers exploited. Discover-Tech bought ads through Google's and Yandex's exchanges and Comcast's Beeswax; those ads "covertly directed millions of devices to contact Candiru's servers, likely for large-scale tracking and reconnaissance," per Citizen Lab.

Notably, Apple has restricted, blocked, or hidden by default all three identifiers the attackers used since ATT launched in 2021. Its browser team said back in 2019 that it treats circumvention of anti-tracking measures "with the same seriousness as exploitation of security vulnerabilities." The WebKit post draws the same line: first-party personalization "is not tracking, and is not what our technologies seek to prevent." A central identity resolver, though, is a third-party "clearinghouse."

Critics note ATT at least asked users for consent, while the blocklist works without input. But users were asked — through the industry's own framework.

Why didn't the vendor lists catch this?

Discover-Tech sat on IAB Europe's Global Vendor List from July 2, 2020 — an association claiming "reasonable steps to vet and approve" applicants, including controlling parties. For most of that period, its records showed spyware-industry links on its board and among shareholders. It was also on Google's Certified External Vendors list. Citizen Lab concludes these lists "appear to be largely based on self-attestation by vendors." Google and IAB Europe acted only after disclosure — Google blocked the company "for systematically violating our policies," and IAB Europe suspended it.

So: can anyone blame Apple for not trusting those lists? Not really. Know Your Customer checks, run by humans, should be the first layer of any ad transaction.

What about publishers?

IAB Tech Lab CEO Anthony Katsur recently wrote that "Ad tech can adapt" — and that the bigger pressure point is publishers relying on third-party identity resolvers, even ones working from logged-in email addresses.

Apple has promised not to touch what media owners always had: their own consented data, used on their own properties. And server-side ID workarounds carry risk; Apple's policy warns circumvention may bring "additional restrictions without prior notice."

The takeaway for premium publishers: first-party data, direct audience relationships, and contextual targeting built on top of both — not the open marketplace, and not ID-based targeting as we knew it.

Cybercrime delivered through advertising is bigger than one spyware vendor and bigger than the Apple argument. The open marketplace will collapse sooner or later; the companies that survive will be the ones selling trust, safety, and transparency, not identity graphs.

Don't blame Apple. Evolve ad tech.

Plot points

  1. On October 15, Confiant and Citizen Lab confirmed a zero-click spyware campaign delivered via ads on more than 120,000 websites and 70,000 apps, targeting Al Jazeera staff.
  2. Since iOS 27 and macOS 27 Golden Gate, Apple WebKit blocks ad tech domains it calls 'identity resolution infrastructure', with no published list and no appeals process.
  3. Discover-Tech sat on IAB Europe's Global Vendor List since July 2, 2020, despite board and shareholder links to the spyware industry.
  4. ID5 CEO Mathieu Roche called the block 'an attack against the business model of the web'; IAB Tech Lab CEO Anthony Katsur counters that 'Ad tech can adapt.'
  5. Apple has restricted all three identifiers the attackers used — mobile ad IDs, cookie IDs, IP addresses — since ATT launched in 2021.

via theguardian.com (Original)

Filed under

  • ad-security
  • identity-resolution
  • apple-webkit
  • spyware
  • contextual-targeting
Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Market editor covering technology and product news in marketing technology at Martech Beacon.

47 articles

Neighbouring fixes

‹ Previous articleNext article ›