Log entry Nº 414 · the stack watch

Bearing E 090° · November 18, 2026 · 5 min read

Commerce TechE 090°Watch log

United's AI agent ban shows brands the cost of the closed door

United's Nov. 11 terms ban unauthorized AI agents from booking or servicing tickets, while Delta, American and JetBlue hedge — exposing the reach-versus-control tradeoff.

By Sophie Lindqvist5 min read912 words

United Airlines crackdown puts personal AI agents to the test
Fix Nº 414United Airlines crackdown puts personal AI agents to the test — 穿着拖鞋一路小跑 / pixabay

On Nov. 11, United Airlines rewrote its website terms and contract of carriage to bar unauthorized third-party AI agents from its platforms, and the fallout is a live case study for every brand building an agentic commerce strategy.

The revised contract blocks unauthorized agents from making, changing or servicing tickets — even under human supervision — and lets United cancel bookings they create. It also requires written permission before an agent can access the site or collect information, though traditional search engines can still index United's content. One detail matters: customer permission alone doesn't authorize an agent. United says it doesn't currently work with any third-party AI agents, though its rules carve out exceptions for certain human-reviewed AI tools used by travel agency employees and rule-based booking automation.

United cited concrete risks: exposure of customer data, unintended purchases, unauthorized account changes, violations of federal aviation regulations, and agents' inability to attest during check-in that passengers' bags contain no prohibited items. The concerns aren't purely technical. CEO Scott Kirby told the Wall Street Journal he didn't want another intermediary between the airline and its customers.

Fair enough. But the bill for that closed door may arrive later.

What does blocking agents actually cost?

The core problem is visibility. Personal AI agents let consumers research, compare and buy through one interface instead of hopping between sites and apps. Block them, and you don't just lose traffic — you may never know you lost anything.

"AI agents are increasingly becoming the entry point for product discovery," said Jaclyn Wands, vice president of product and AI at Phaedon, a loyalty tech and services company. "When consumers delegate research to an assistant, the agent builds a shortlist before they visit a company's site or app."

That shortlist is the new shelf. Customers who hit a block can simply move to competitors, giving the original business less control over how its products are presented. Wands added a sharper point: "Even longtime customers could look like first-time buyers if agents can't access their loyalty status, rewards and preferences." Your CRM's prized personalization, meet the anonymous doorway.

Access versus control — where should the line sit?

Rich Pleeth, CEO and co-founder of Finmile, which builds AI workers for logistics and physical operations, argues for a split: give approved agents limited access to product information while keeping purchases and account changes on a tight leash. Companies should separate permission to compare from permission to buy.

"Companies could let approved agents retrieve prices and availability while requiring explicit customer authorization for purchases, substitutions or account changes," he said.

United's own contract shows why the distinction matters. When the FAA issued a nationwide ground stop on Nov. 13 — a communications outage at air traffic control centers disrupted more than 10,000 flights — stranded passengers needed rebooking fast. United bars unauthorized agents from servicing tickets even with a person supervising, raising questions about whether agents could help passengers rebook during exactly this kind of disruption. Information quality matters too: "Agents might favor a competitor if a seller can't confirm product availability or delivery, even when it offers a lower price," Pleeth said.

How are other airlines handling it?

The industry isn't united, so to speak:

  • Delta supports certain authenticated interactions with external AI assistants while building its own agentic customer-service capabilities. It relies on login credentials and puts responsibility on the customer.
  • American Airlines has indicated some AI tools can facilitate ticket purchases, though it hasn't specified which booking steps those tools can perform.
  • JetBlue said the airline should adapt if customers increasingly use AI booking agents, while raising concerns about distribution costs.

United claims its systems can distinguish an agent booking from one made by a traveler or travel agency, and it warns that sharing credentials with an AI assistant can expose sensitive information. The split reflects the broader enterprise menu: block agents, grant controlled access, or build your own.

What about security and the fee question?

Saurabh Pitkar, director of product management for agentic commerce and agentic AI at Dell Technologies, points to account linking as the mechanism — identifying customers and letting agents pull loyalty benefits without exposing entire accounts. "Businesses will need to figure out how to bring guardrails and protocols that allow external third-party agents to securely perform tasks on behalf of customers," he said, citing role-based access controls, security measures and fraud controls as core safeguards.

Then there's the economics. Wands cautioned that customers may stick with the third-party assistants they already use, so building proprietary agents doesn't guarantee adoption. Partnering with external platforms reaches them — but invites distribution fees and platform dependence. Pleeth's warning is blunt: "Someone who previously booked directly on an airline's website might start booking through an assistant, creating a new fee without bringing in a new customer."

A PYMTS survey of 60 senior e-commerce decision makers at U.S. merchants found most expect merchants to pay fees or commissions on completed agent-driven sales. So measure ruthlessly. "Businesses should measure completed purchases, repeat transactions and margins after platform fees, fulfillment, returns and support costs," Pleeth said — and track whether agent-driven sales actually grow revenue or just shift direct bookings onto fee-charging platforms.

The verdict for practitioners: agentic commerce isn't a yes-or-no decision, it's an access-control design problem with a P&L attached.

Plot points

  1. United updated its contract of carriage on Nov. 11 to bar unauthorized third-party AI agents from making, changing or servicing tickets, even under human supervision.
  2. A Nov. 13 FAA nationwide ground stop disrupted more than 10,000 flights, testing whether agents can help rebook under United's restrictions.
  3. A PYMTS survey of 60 senior U.S. e-commerce decision makers found most expect merchants to pay fees on completed agent-driven sales.
  4. Delta, American and JetBlue are each allowing some form of AI-assisted interaction, unlike United's blanket restriction.
  5. United CEO Scott Kirby said he doesn't want another intermediary between the airline and its customers.

via techtarget.com (Source)

Filed under

  • agentic-commerce
  • ai-agents
  • access-control
  • airline-technology
  • e-commerce
Share this article:

More from Sophie Lindqvist

Sophie Lindqvist

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in marketing technology at Martech Beacon.

46 articles

Neighbouring fixes

‹ Previous article